Waterstones are a soft stone (usually) and use only water. They need to be soaked first before being used. They also need to be flattened periodically. Carborundum can be used dry. But you will get a smoother more polished surface on your blade with oil. Sort of makes a thin grinding compound.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a1b7b/a1b7b4916049b50ec86557388a0c52755d33ba67" alt=""